我们招生的时候会有匿名的人发链接来说复旦经管班如何如何黑暗
学霸太多太凶残，这学期七门专业课都有人17.5学分绩点4.0的
shushubang
2011/11/30 14:41:42
在豆瓣上看一个关于金融学中国各大学排名。。。
指的是本科：THU>PKU(GSM)>Renmin/SJTU>>>>Fudan/SHUFE（上财）/UIBE（对外经贸）/CUFE（央财）
（看到上海交大远大于复旦觉得很扯。。。）
那个人的解释是 复旦金融隶属经济学院，在课程设置上有点过时。学生主体很优秀，少数人去咨询，大多数人去四大或商行。。。他用英语写的，不太看得懂。他觉得人大强是出国方面......贴过来，有兴趣的就看看吧。后面还黑了不少学校= =
我个人今年被经管预录，实在没什么了解，貌似最难进的就是国际金融系了，还是听听各位前辈的实战经验比较靠谱。
first of all, if you mean top 10 US PhD program in Finance, everyone knows they prefer highly quantitative background rather than finance. In US, most of MSF programs are post-experience, which means, not for academic career. They shoule have similar view of Chinese Master in Finance. To my konwledge, a bunch of top-toer don't recruit Phd in Finance directly from mainland China.
If you mean Top 10 MBA, of course, your w/e really counts, and your undergraduate GPA(irrelevant with your pg study actually)
Regarding domestic finance program rankings, I can only comment only some programs in terms of placement, mainly in undergraduate side.
IMO, THU>PKU(GSM)>Renmin/SJTU>>>>Fudan/SHUFE/UIBE/CUFE.
Fudan undergraduate finance program is affiliated to their school of econ, which is kinda outdated in curriculum. their student body quite good, yet placement not very good.Some outliers may find employment in consulting firms, but the majority are still big 4/commercial banks.
Tsinghua SEM, I've known a bunch of their ug students in CICC IBD, given the small class body, really excellent placements. GSM isn't bad, no comment for CCER as it only runs a minor bachelor degree with huge student body.
Renmin has a tradition of going abroad, I know one guy in Philips Trainee, back from LSE, one girl in IB in the City of London, and another girl works in HK.
SJTU, ASOM ug isn't that good. But I know their master interns in BAH, Bain, some PE, though their student body is small. And we need to closely monitor how well the new SAIF program runs.
SHUFE/UIBE are actually in a same level, except that UIBE has better placements in public sector.:) Viva SHUFE!
Please be aware, CUFE now also has very good placements, though its faculty and curriculum are out of the league.
Regaring NANKAI, WHU, I just know their alumni always go to Shenzhen/Greater Pearl River Region. In Chinese, 在那边比较会混.
In terms of faculty. WHU post-graduate students' placement is dismal actually.
I don't really think Nankai has a strong faculty any more, though Wu Shulian gives it high ratings, their faculty is poor, no matter how many adjectives and titles used before their prof's names. Quite similar to PKU School of Econ, just waste student's time.
UIBE B-school is ridiculous, I've never seen any prof use professional designation to propaganda him/herself in top-ranked b-schools. Their dean seems ver proud of his FCCA, yet many SHUFE ACCA class alumni can easily attain FCCA, within 5 years after they qualified ACCA. UIBE's designated professors just because ACCA initially came to China to talk with Peking bureaucrats.
I personally think, Zhongshan, Shufe are at the same level in the industry, whether average or top guys in undergraduate programs. I can name Bei Duiguang(MD,CICC), Jerry Lou(China Strategist, MS),Jiang Jianqing(Chairman, ICBC),from SHUFE, Fang Fenglei(co-founder, CICC) from Zhongshan.
XJTU, play with themself, their no.1 ranking in mgt, is totally a CRAP. The same logic if you distrust Philipine's top-ranked b-school.
爱上swesty
2011/11/30 22:09:16
国际金融很强，其他就没这么厉害了～
→_→再看我就把你吃掉！！！